Wireset
Roundup
by: Titan
Wireset round up
Which spark plug wires are the best? Does price always dictate performance?
Are aftermarket wire sets that much better? And are they worth the
money? These are questions that I've set out to answer. With a limited
budget in mind, I set out to show you some alternatives to the high
dollar performance wire sets.
I have rounded up eight of the more common spark plug wire sets
that you will encounter while shopping at your local D.I.Y. Automotive
stores. I review 2 sets from Advanced auto parts, 3 sets from Autozone,
1 set from Genuine and 1 from Main auto parts, and finally 1 wireset
from Pep boys. I'm limited in my testing procedures so I concentrate
on the ohms of resistance within the wires. This review, well not
definitive, will give you an idea of what your hard earned money
is buying.
Tale of the tape
Every manufacturer touts there wires as the best and its easy to
get lost in the sea of hype. So, I have composed a list of some
of these "incredible" features here:
Ultra-tough jacketing prevents terminal pull-off
Resists heat, oil, chemicals and abrasions under the most demanding
conditions
Fiberglass braid provides strength and flexibility
Snap lock terminals provide positive connection and resist corrosion
Heavy duty silicon boots
High energy suppresser delivers maximum voltage without radio interference
OE fit for easy installation
EPDM inner insulation to stop power-robbing voltage leaks
Kevlar reinforced core fore long life
Durable stainless steel alloy winding
Extra thick higtemp silicone jacket
and so on and so forth...
Basically, all of the printed features are the same. They are all
just a rehash of what you read here. Now on to the tests!
Testing procedures
Each spark plug wire was probed three times with an ohm meter. Each
time the testing electrodes were completely removed from the wire
and then the wires were reprobed. The average reading (located in
the table below) was taken by adding the wire's three test numbers
and dividing by the number of times tested (3). Furthermore, the
wires are listed from longest to shortest ie. #1 in the table would
be the longest wire while #4 would be the shortest of the four wires.
Results
Store/Brand*
|
part #
|
street
price
|
average reading
|
dielectric
grease
|
#1
|
#2
|
#3
|
#4
|
Advanced
|
|
Xact |
3148
|
$28.94
|
18.47
|
16.98
|
17.21
|
10.66
|
none
|
Autolite professional |
96870
|
$26.94
|
8.99
|
8.28
|
7.56
|
7.52
|
pre greased
|
Autozone
|
|
Ultra spark |
4666
|
$24.99
|
6.37
|
6.42
|
6.03
|
5.06
|
pre greased
|
Bosh* |
09418
|
$34.99
|
1.18
|
1.01
|
11.00
|
.64
|
pre greased
|
Carol spark |
A9561
|
$24.99
|
8.68
|
10.41
|
7.74
|
6.35
|
pre greased
|
Genuine
|
|
Champion power |
700020
|
$21.38
|
10.28
|
10.08
|
8.79
|
5.69
|
packet
|
Main
|
|
Standard plus |
7540
|
$19.89
|
9.16
|
7.27
|
6.55
|
6.03
|
packet
|
Pepboys
|
|
Borg warner* |
6-99-029-21186
|
$27.99
|
1.25
|
1.25
|
1.01
|
.726
|
packet
|
* Denotes a lifetime warranty
All wires tested were 7mm
As you can see there is a big difference in the resistance between
the wires. Also, even though on average the Bosh wires had the least
resistance of the eight the #3 wire tested bad. This observation
brings up a good point about wiresets and that is upon purchasing
a wireset you may want to check the resistance before installing
them on your car to be sure that they are all within a similar range.
The winner in the end is the Bosh wireset closly followed by the
Borg Warner brand. The numbers are close enough to warrent a tie
and between the two and I don't really see a difference since they
are both quality wiresets. In the end it will come down to your
preference between the two.
Conclusion
If you have read the Magnecor, or any, write up on spark plug wires
you maybe saying to yourself "low resistance is not a complete
test of a good spark plug wire" and I would agree with you.
There are several other factors that come into play when choosing
a wire set like EMI (electromagnetic interference) and RFI (radio
frequency interference) suppression but unfortunately, there is
no way for me to test for this type of interference. I don't believe
that this is a big issue for Saturn cars in general since there
are only four relatively short spark plug wires, leaving less area
for electromagnetic interference to be produced. EMI and RFI would
be a greater concern if you are running aftermarket engine management
systems.
Marketers of performance wiresets often target consumers with high-powered
aftermarket ignitions, which tend to burn the wires out faster.
Since I believe that the Saturn's ignition system is adequate enough
for even moderately boosted applications (5-10psi of boost) there
is no need to upgrade to a performance ignition system unless you
are planning to boost higher. In the end this will save you a lot
of money considering ignition systems for Saturn's range in the
300-400 dollar range not including performance wires. An aftermarket
ignition system will give you a few extra horsepower but the price
to performance payoff, in my opinion, is not worth the investment.
Summing it all up
Expensive aftermarket wires on average, cost twice as much as off
the shelf D.I.Y store brands and they don't carry a lifetime warranty
but for around $30 I can easily purchase a wireset that in reality
probably gives me 80-90% of the aftermarket performance. If you
are concerned about your wires burning out quickly from high under-hood
temperatures or your aggressive driving style you're covered. The
lifetime warranty has its advantages
|